Otaku4life

Like how animecountryboy said, I think it depends on how well the voice fits into a character. For example, on Clannad I prefer Eng. Sub because the Japanese VAs fit much more with the characters. Eng. dub is good, but sub is just slightly better for that anime in my opinion. On Fruits Basket I prefer Eng. Dub because the VA's fit with the character and you can feel emotion coming from them. That and Laura Bailey is one of my favorite Dub VAs. That's how I feel